ITP – Coach’s Corner
About Coach’s Corner
In the best of all worlds, clinical practice guidelines provide recommendations about diagnosis and treatment that are based on solid evidence from phase 3 clinical trials. In many cases, such evidence does not exist and recommendations are provided based on expert opinion. Even then, many questions pertinent to clinical care may be left out of guidelines. In Coach’s Corner, we aim to address some of these gaps by surveying the opinion of clinical experts from the TBP board of advisors in areas where there exists a gray zone. This exercise is not meant to provide definitive guidance for patient care, but rather is designed to highlight the importance of clinical experience and critical thinking in the decision making process.
The opinions presented in this case were obtained in May 2022, and may be subject to change as new evidence emerges.
Question 1
Background: In this case study, we discussed that first-line therapy in a patient with newly diagnosed immune thrombocytopenia (ITP) includes corticosteroids, administered in one of two ways: prednisone 1 mg/kg daily with tapering doses over 6 weeks or dexamethasone 40 mg daily for 4 days. The use of high dose (“pulse”) dexamethasone is based on the results of one small randomized control trial. Clinical practice guidelines do not favor one regimen over the other, so we asked our experts:
Question: In a patient with newly diagnosed ITP, which do you prefer administering and why?
- Prednisone 1 mg/kg/day with taper over 6 weeks
- Dexamethasone 40 mg daily x 4 days
Jason A. Freed, MD
Hematology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Harvard Medical School
Click for Jason’s answerDexamethasone 40 mg daily x 4 is my treatment of choice for essentially all patients with newly diagnosed ITP because it “concentrates the pain” of steroids into a short duration and (based upon one small RCT) has slightly better outcomes. Continued here.
Brian J. Carney, MD
Hematology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Harvard Medical School
Click for Brian’s answerWilliam C. Aird, MD
Hematology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Harvard Medical School
Click for Bill’s answerRushad Patell, MD
Hematology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Harvard Medical School
Click for Rushad’s answerI do not have a strong preference over either in clinical practice. I will often end up using prednisone, as it allows me to more flexibility to taper and the dosing. Moreover in the outpatient setting, practically I can use dose adjustments as second reason to justify the frequent and close laboratory monitoring.
Reed E. Drews, MD
Hematology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Harvard Medical School
Click for Reed’s answerI prefer a schedule of daily prednisone as the steroid regimen for newly diagnosed ITP, but I believe 6 weeks is far too short, as many patients who are steroid-responsive will “relapse” with rapid tapers. Continued here.
Anish V. Sharda, MD
Hematology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Harvard Medical School
Click for Anish’s answerJeffrey I. Zwicker, MD
Hematology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Harvard Medical School
Click for Jeff’s answerMarcel M. Levi, MD
Amsterdam University Medical Centers, University of Amsterdam
Click for Marcel’s answerQuestion 2
Background: For diagnostic work up of immune thrombocytopenia (ITP) there is consensus among clinical practice guidelines to test for HIV and HCV, because treatment of an underlying viral infection may improved platelet counts. There is some discordance in recommendation about whether and when to test for immune globulin levels (to rule out combined variable immunodeficiency syndrome) or Helicobacter pylori.
Test | ICR | ASH |
---|---|---|
Complete blood count | In all adults with newly diagnosed ITP. | In all adults with newly diagnosed ITP. |
Peripheral smear | In all adults with newly diagnosed ITP. | In all adults with newly diagnosed ITP. |
HIV and HCV | “The majority of authors routinely test” for these viruses. | Recommended in all adults with newly diagnosed ITP. |
HBV | “The majority of authors routinely test” for these viruses. | Not mentioned, though an earlier ASH guideline in 2011 refers to “hepatitis serology before rituximab”. |
Quantitative immunoglobulin levels | Indicated to exclude an immune deficiency syndrome or before treatment with IVIG. | Not mentioned |
Helicobacter pylori | Urea breath test or the stool antigen test, should be included in the initial work-up in appropriate geographical areas. | Screening for H pylori be considered for patients with ITP in whom eradication therapy would be used if testing is positive. |
Bone marrow examination | In those relapsing after remission, in patients not responding to initial treatment options, where splenectomy is considered, or if other abnormalities are detected in the blood count or morphology. | A bone marrow examination is not necessary irrespective of age for patients presenting with typical ITP. |
We asked our experts:
Question: In addition to a complete blood count, differential, peripheral smear, HCV and HIV serologies, what tests if any do you routinely order in a patient with a suspected diagnosis of ITP?
Jason A. Freed, MD
Hematology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Harvard Medical School
Click for Jason’s answerI rule out hemolysis if any anemia, even if mild. I check HBV in case I want to use rituximab later. I check PT/PTT and liver function tests on everyone. I don’t do quantitative immunoglobulins without a suggestive history. I don’t do H. pylori unless GI symptoms since I’m not convinced by the data that treating it helps ITP in unselected populations. Continued here.
Brian J. Carney, MD
Hematology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Harvard Medical School
Click for Brian’s answerWilliam C. Aird, MD
Hematology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Harvard Medical School
Click for Bill’s answerRushad Patell, MD
Hematology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Harvard Medical School
Click for Rushad’s answerI usually also test for Hepatitis B (but mostly because I will often reach for rituximab after steroids). I tend to test for H pylori in certain populations (like people that have spent time in high risk parts of the world). Since H pylori is a stool based test at my institution, I use it less and less. I do not routinely send immune globulin levels.
Reed E. Drews, MD
Hematology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Harvard Medical School
Click for Reed’s answerAnish V. Sharda, MD
Hematology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Harvard Medical School
Click for Anish’s answerJeffrey I. Zwicker, MD
Hematology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Harvard Medical School
Click for Jeff’s answerMarcel M. Levi, MD
Amsterdam University Medical Centers, University of Amsterdam
Click for Marcel’s answerQuestion 3
Background: Patients with immune thrombocytopenia (ITP) and severe thrombocytopenia are at increased risk of serious bleeding. An important and often challenging question is when should such a patient be admitted to hospital?
- The 2019 ASH guideline recommends admitting patients with newly diagnosed ITP and a platelet count of <20 x 109/L. In adults with an established diagnosis of ITP and a platelet count of <20 x 109/L who are asymptomatic or have minor mucocutaneous bleeding, the ASH guideline panel suggests outpatient management rather than hospital admission who are asymptomatic or have minor mucocutaneous bleeding.
- The 2019 International Consensus Report does not provide graded recommendations for inpatient vs. outpatient treatment of adult patients with newly diagnosed ITP, but they do write: “Therapy for ITP can be given as an outpatient in most situations, unless there is active bleeding or other medical variables (anticoagulant therapy), the patient requires close monitoring, or it is the initial presentation for thrombocytopenia and platelets are < 20 x 109/L.”
We asked our experts:
Question: What is your threshold for admitting a patient with ITP to the hospital. More specifically, would you admit one of both of the following patients:
- PATIENT 1: Newly diagnosed ITP with PLT count < 10 x 109/L, petechiae, no mucosal bleeding
- PATIENT 2: Newly diagnosed ITP with PLT count 10-20 x 109/L, petechiae, no mucosal bleeding
Jason A. Freed, MD
Hematology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Harvard Medical School
Click for AnswerI admit patients with platelets<20 or bleeding, if they are newly diagnosed (therefore I don’t know yet what treatment they will respond to or how quickly). I would admit patient 1. I would likely admit patient 2. especially if it’s an older adult with other major medical issues or risk to fall. Continued here.
Brian J. Carney, MD
Hematology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Harvard Medical School
Click for AnswerWilliam C. Aird, MD
Hematology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Harvard Medical School
Click for AnswerI generally admit patients with a platelet count < 10K whether or not they are bleeding (e.g., patient 1), though I might increase that threshold to 20K if the patient is at higher risk for bleeding (e.g., taking anticoagulant, or elderly and at risk for fall). I feel strongly about the importance of shared decision making in these cases.
Rushad Patell, MD
Hematology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Harvard Medical School
Click for AnswerI am generally comfortable managing someone as an outpatient with newly diagnosed ITP with a platelet count of >20K as long as I can ensure laboratory studies multiple times a week. If there is concern for bleeding, platelets <20K, or if its not feasible to ensure very close follow up I would prefer admitting.
Reed E. Drews, MD
Hematology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Harvard Medical School
Click for Reed’s answerAnish V. Sharda, MD
Hematology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Harvard Medical School
Click for Anish’s answerJeffrey I. Zwicker, MD
Hematology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Harvard Medical School
Click for Jeff’s answerMarcel M. Levi, MD
Amsterdam University Medical Centers, University of Amsterdam
Click for Marcel’s answerQuestion 4
Background: The clinical practice guidelines have distinct recommendations for emergency treatment of ITP that includes corticosteroids, IVIG, platelet transfusions, and other measures.
ASH 2011* | ICR | |
---|---|---|
Definition | Emergency management of ITP refers to treatment of those patients with life-, limb-, or sight-threatening hemorrhage. | Treatment of patients presenting with severe bleeding manifestations, particularly if the platelet count is < 20 x 109/L, including those with active central nervous system, gastrointestinal, or genitourinary bleeding. |
Treatment | IVIG, corticosteroids, platelet transfusion, recombinant factor VIIa, antifibrinolytic agents, and (rarely) emergency splenectomy. | Corticosteroids, IVIG, e platelet transfusion, possibly combined with IVIG, and emergency splenectomy; Although TPO-RAs take >5 days to initiate a response, and rituximab usually takes 3 to 4 weeks, early administration of either might be considered. |
Note: Bleeding that requires “emergency management” is not the same as “severe” bleeding. The International Working Group defines “severe or clinically relevant” bleeding as the presence of symptoms at presentation sufficient to mandate treatment or by the occurrence of new bleeding symptoms requiring additional therapeutic intervention with a different platelet enhancing agent or an increase in dose of current therapy. They agreed that a bleeding manifestation can generally be labeled “severe or clinically relevant” if it is grade 3 for skin and/or grade 2 or higher for mucosal domains
and/or higher than grade 1 for organ domain (definitions for these grades can be found here).
Question: We posed three clinical scenarios with different levels of bleeding severity to our experts and asked who qualifies for “emergency treatment” with corticosteroids, IVIG and platelet transfusion:
- PATIENT 1: Newly diagnosed ITP with PLT count < 10K, petechiae, no mucosal bleeding
- PATIENT 2: Newly diagnosed ITP with PLT count < 10K, petechiae, oral wet purpura
- PATIENT 3: Newly diagnosed ITP with PLT count < 10K, petechiae, GI bleeding
Jason A. Freed, MD
Hematology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Harvard Medical School
Click for Answer- Patient 1: Does not qualify, but if platelets <5K (i.e., undetectable in our lab) I might give IVIG with steroids (no platelets).
- Patient 2: Yes, qualifies for emergency treatment, though I might try IVIG and steroids without platelet transfusion.
- Patient 3: Yes, qualifies. I would administer the kitchen sink with IVIG, platelet transfusions and steroids.
Brian J. Carney, MD
Hematology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Harvard Medical School
Click for AnswerWilliam C. Aird, MD
Hematology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Harvard Medical School
Click for AnswerRushad Patell, MD
Hematology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Harvard Medical School
Click for AnswerReed E. Drews, MD
Hematology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Harvard Medical School
Click for Reed’s answerAnish V. Sharda, MD
Hematology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Harvard Medical School
Click for Anish’s answerJeffrey I. Zwicker, MD
Hematology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Harvard Medical School
Click for Jeff’s answerMarcel M. Levi, MD
Amsterdam University Medical Centers, University of Amsterdam
Click for Marcel’s answerQuestion 5
Background: The threshold for treating patients with immune thrombocytopenia (ITP) is generally accepted as 20-30 x 109/L.
- The ASH guideline writes: “In adults with newly diagnosed ITP and a platelet count of <30 x 109/L who are asymptomatic or have minor mucocutaneous bleeding, the American Society of Hematology (ASH) guideline panel suggests corticosteroids rather than management with observation. ”
- The ICR report writes: “Treatment should maintain a target platelet level >20-30 x 109/L at least for symptomatic patients (because risk for major bleeding increases below this level).”
Should we adjust our platelet threshold for a patient who is taking anticoagulants? If so, to what level?
- ASH qualifies their threshold of <30 x 109/L: “There may be a subset of patients within this group for whom observation might be appropriate. This should include consideration of the severity of thrombocytopenia, additional comorbidities, use of anticoagulant or antiplatelet medications, need for upcoming procedures, and age of the patient.”
- The ICR report: “The platelet count should be improved to attain a minimum of 20 to 30 x 109/L, but there is no need to normalize the platelet count; however, this level may not be appropriate for patients who are active or older than 60 years of age (several studies have shown increased rates of bleeding, thrombosis, and death in patients older than 60 years), patients with other comorbidities, or those on anticoagulants. Consensus-based recommendation for target platelet counts for surgery or medical therapy in adults taking anticoagulants was 30-50 x 109/L.”
We asked our experts:
Question: What is an acceptable platelet count threshold in a patient with ITP who is on a DOAC?
Jason A. Freed, MD
Hematology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Harvard Medical School
Click for AnswerBrian J. Carney, MD
Hematology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Harvard Medical School
Click for AnswerWilliam C. Aird, MD
Hematology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Harvard Medical School
Click for AnswerRushad Patell, MD
Hematology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Harvard Medical School
Click for AnswerReed E. Drews, MD
Hematology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Harvard Medical School
Click for Reed’s answerAnish V. Sharda, MD
Hematology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Harvard Medical School
Click for Anish’s answerJeffrey I. Zwicker, MD
Hematology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Harvard Medical School
Click for Jeff’s answerMarcel M. Levi, MD
Amsterdam University Medical Centers, University of Amsterdam
Click for Marcel’s answer